SBenegaL

Category: Society

  • GOD and the notion of Uncertainty…

    The nothing of GOD is extremely intriguing. All of us have different notions of the Generator, Observer and Destroyers (GOD) based on our own experiences. Yes I said Experiences – read on to see why I make this claim. 
    One of the comments on my last blog on the trinity of Hindu Mythology and the possible purpose behind the design mentioned – 
    “Wonderful Article 🙂
    Reading this, I could not help myself but think
    these gods are man-made; they represent what our ancestors thought a
    wise idea worth sharing. However, the mystery is not solved yet. I just
    wanted to point out, I personally feel there is nothing divine and
    supernatural about gods as they have been portrayed for millenia!”     
    – Anonymous
    The comment got me thinking about why the notion of divinity and supernatural ability might have been attributed to GODs. I think I possibly got the answer! or may be not! However this is definitely an interesting thought – worth sharing. 

    Scientific Thinking which found its feet has been built on the concept of reasoning. The ability to question and associate a cause and affect relationship has definitely served the human society well. The near exponential growth in the number of invention, and its commercialization that has quickened the pace of economic growth and gotten more CERTAINTY into our lives. 
    Extending this, the possible origin of the notion of God, then has to be on the other extreme – when one feels or experiences UNCERTAINTY. These two observations sort of reinforce my interpretation.
    1. The first one is definitely from my own personal experience of facing uncertainty which is so much a part of the entreprenuerial journey.
    2. The existence of a high belief rate in God in the lower economic strata of society!
     Let me try explain this observation a bit elaborately:
    As an entrepreneur and you will realize the complexity of the issues that (s)he faces from various directions and the limited cognitive ability wouldn’t be completely enough to handle this. Even effectuation strategy, which through its principles provides a very very effective way to handle this entrepreneurial uncertainty, acknowledges the role of surprises (Lemonade Principle). In handling such a high uncertain situation where the distrution is unknown and hence a risk cannot be associated requires one to be positive and optimistic all through – and also believe in the strength of miracles. Miracles that just emerge when you least expect it – while some could attribute it to luck, it could also be attributed to the ability of God to influence things in one’s favor. An extension of the above claim where this relation of uncertainly in business and a religious bent of mind can be seen in most businessmen being devout to a specific deity.
    I also extend this uncertainty to the economically weaker sections of the society, where people have no idea where their next day’s meal would come from! The physical strength, minimum skill and the effort of these people is all that they would need to rely on in being able to sustain themselves on a day to day basis. This is possibly one of the reasons why this section of the society is highly susceptible to religious conversions – when there is a slightly better quality of life could be expected!
    PS: The above is just a thought that I put across and would appreciate your  feedback on the same.

  • “Remote Culture” – Get up and change it…



    A short while after I woke up today morning I checked my facebook page for some inspirational quote, and lo! I found this.
    I have been thinking of the declining willingness in today’s generation to bend their back! and feel this quote kind of helps me put these thoughts together. 

    All through my childhood, growing up as the only child to my parents it seems to me that my parents should have logically pampered me. I thanks them today for the emphasis they put on hardwork and patience. I increasingly find this emphasis on hard-work becoming a rarity thesedays. 
    Most of the students I interact with have grown up in with a lot more attention from their parents (unlike the old Indian kids where the parental attention was divided between almost half a dozen kids!). The higher attention typically translates to parental attempts in ensuring the kid almost everything (s)he wants! Beginning to rely completely on the “remote culture” as I call it. An extremely easy way to get things done – almost at the click of a button!

    While this parental attention is great, the repercussions begin impacting nearly a decade and half later, when they are either doing their graduation or are in their work environments. The certainty that was so much a part of the growth years, all of a sudden seems to disappear and the harder realities of life which require one to stretch and get the better of oneself takes over. 

    The reactions of the individual in these situations is to either accept the new norm and retain the current pace of activity, or to try and push and may be eventually give up. The major issue is when one stops experimenting and exploring and eventually morphing to be ready for the challenges of everyday life.

    If there is someone who can change what we want to change it is us alone.

  • Why dont students challenge the exisiting norms?

    We really don’t find students challenge their teachers today? This is so much an Indian phenomenon…
    This is how one of the conversation started today with Rishi… yes, Rishi and I keep discussing quite a few topics relating to the education in India. 
    In this case it was interesting – I for one have not seen many of my students challenge me on the concept, I have seen some students who did try to put me out of the comfort zone due to attitude issues, but not on the subject matter. This too synched with what Rishi had observed, however I differed on his overall assessment that this was an Indian Phenomenon. 
    We have heard about Gargi or Maitreyi who had been in a detailed discussion with the renowned saints of Janaka’s period on various topics which required tremendous expertise. So it is not possible that discussion or even dissenting with the opinion of one’s teacher is completely unheard of. In fact most of the early scriptures from here are in the from of a discussion and highlighting the nuances of the knowledge/philosophy. The drawback however was that not many were exposed to the knowledge as it was transmitted orally as the primary means and the written scripts were accessible only to a select few. 
    I would rather blame the reason for suppression of the questioning mindset to the period when the system of knowledge transfer was broken thanks to the fear! Yes, the history of India has had enormous challenge to the survival of the religion of the masses at least a couple of times during the Mughal Period and later on during the British Rule. People being closely attached towards religion, feared the influence of the new beliefs and tried to avoid their religion being taken away! They possibly tried to prevent questioning of the fundamentals of their own religion under the influence of the new thoughts and began suppressing the thought of a creative discussion. 
    Coupled with this, the system of generating mass scale clerks through the education system that was introduced during the British Era only worsened the problem. You needed people who could follow instructions while not really applying their minds!
    The effect we see of this – is today in the form of people who dont think independently or question the foundation and belief!
    The way forward I see is to encourage discussion as part of the knowledge discovery and dissemination. It is only through effective dialogue and discussion that one develops Independently thinking individuals who could fearlessly voice their opinions.

  • An exciting journey of starting a society – extremely satisfying

    My life has been a summation of various experiments that I have been venturing on – many of the decision I have taken and followed have really no rationale description that even I could give – forget a prescription. Experimenting with uncertainty is now a part of me… and when some of these experiments make way to something that is extremely tangible there is no bound for the satisfaction and happiness I experience.
    A recent such venture that sprouted into an organization has been setting up our own – Amba Bhavani Vividoddesha Souharda Sahakari. A cooperative which today almost every one from my community says there has been a felt need – their argument goes saying – “every other community in the region has one and we are late – none the less – better late than never”. 
    I possibly wouldn’t have ventured onto this one if it was not for a dear friend of mine – Murali who was helping me explore the possibility of owning a house in my home town – Udupi. It was he who really was the guy who sowed the seed into my head… 
    Frankly, I didn’t know much about Cooperative Society to begin with – it was entirely a new field. I just waited on for Murali to repeat his idea so that I am really sure he was interested in it – and yes he was… I kept hearing the enthusiastic idea again and again. 
    Being in Bangalore, I knew it would be relatively difficult for me to really venture out to Udupi and attempt setting up the society – I instead thought it would be best if I could focus on getting people involved into this venture. I realized that banking would be a crucial part of this venture and so, the first person whom I got on board was Manjunath Uncle…
    I discussed the idea with him and then connected Murali and uncle to chalk out the list of people we could get on board… the first of this was my father and then we went on to add in a lot more experienced people onto the list of directors and slowly we could see the action begining.
    There was still some doubt and skepticism, but these were put to rest as the team began to speak with each other. There was then the phase were people would keep meeting to chalk out the plan of action, but it wouldnt take a kick start and begin moving… I had my doubts of this begining to take off really, but thanks to the energy of uncle the engine slowly began moving….
    We got a provisional approval for the process of making shareholder… this was possibly the toughest task of the whole process thus far. We were given 15 days and were asked to make 500 members and raise a certain capital to show that the people on whose behalf we were really attempting this were also seeing the need for it. 
    Several several full-days and evening hours of pursuing finally bore results – reached the target well within the time and submitted our application… but then… the assembly elections were announced. 
    We were this close to finishing the process of registration and now we had to wait for two reasons – there was a change in the act that would define how we were to proceed next, and the second when the new act would really come into effect…. even bigger wait was… when would the time come for us to start after the elections…
    All we could do was just wait… after nearly 4 months of waiting finally we got the go ahead from the department and it was time we came out….
    The society was inaugurated after a long delay but yes.. it gives me great pleasure to see it live on the ground. I know our task is just beginning – there is a tougher challenge ahead – that of really executing the plan ahead…. lets hope by God’s grace we build on this start…
    Wishing all the best to the team and seeking the continued support of all involved…